Can You Negotiate With a Warming Planet?

Photograph by Anadolu / Getty Images

Can You Negotiate With a Warming Planet?

words by miranda green

Each week, award-winning climate journalist Miranda Green offers a look beneath the climate headlines—into how decisions are being made, why they matter, and what they reveal about this moment. Subscribe to The Understory to never miss an edition.

Whether you watched in August as flash floods floated away Nepalese homes, were in western Europe or the continental United States during their hottest summers on record this year, or have read about the ocean swallowing Solomon Islands shorelines at a rate of 10 millimeters every year since the ‘90s, it’s increasingly impossible to deny that climate change is a present and ongoing threat that requires mitigation.

 

That reality is the central tenet of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference in Türkiye, where representatives from more than 190 countries and the European Union—along with environmentalists, activists, and major business leaders—are actively debating how best to address an ever-warming globe. 

 

As is often the case at COP, a major power dynamic is on display between developing nations, rich countries, and the industries responsible for creating the climate crisis.

 

COP31 attendees are still focused largely on calling out the industries and countries most responsible for warming temperatures. They’re urging action to remediate consequential climate impacts in vulnerable communities, and asking for a firm recognition of fossil fuels as the main source of climate change—and for a commitment to pivot away from them now.

 

“The actions from those in power here are completely detached from reality,” activist Greta Thunberg remarked at the international climate summit last week. “The planet is not dying; it is being killed, and we know by who, and it’s being killed by the very same people often thought to come to our rescue. No one is coming to our rescue.”

 

Outgoing U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres used his final COP31 address to appeal for immediate climate intervention. 

 

“You cannot build peace on a burning planet,” he said. “Facts are facts. And the fact is, climate change does not stay in its lane. It drives hunger and displacement around the world. It wipes out development gains built over decades. It pushes countries deeper into debt. It aggravates competition for land and water. It fuels instability. And, increasingly, it threatens the very existence of communities and countries.”

 

But already it seems the prevailing belief is that it might be another year of limited agreement and achievements.

Room for Negotiation?

COP31 discussions are happening against a background of climate realism. 

 

Estimates suggest this year’s record-setting summer heat in Western Europe led to more than 50,000 deaths in urban areas across the continent. Stateside, a wet El Niño season, boosted by the impacts of climate change, gained intensity this fall. Rising ocean levels sent massive waves and catastrophic flooding to West Coast communities from central California to Washington. In Türkiye, extreme weather is leading to a crisis for some farmers. And in Australia, the co-host of this year’s COP, El Niño is on full display as residents prep for an even higher-than-usual fire risk as they head into their summer. 

 

Climate-related issues recently led to some political gains for environmentalists, including Brazil’s recent re-election of left-wing leader Lula da Silva, and Democratic landslide victories in the U.S. midterms that voters delivered in large part as a rebuke to high gas prices and data centers.

 

But at COP, there still appears to be a reluctance, and no consensus, among major world leaders on committing to any binding climate language. 

 

And that’s a big problem. 

 

Last year, how world leaders left the summit was widely seen as a COP-out and failure. The hope was that countries would leave the conference with a commitment, or even a framework, for transitioning away from fossil fuels by a certain timeline. They didn’t. Instead, there was some lip service about making gains at some future time. This past April, over 50 countries met in Colombia under a pledge to make the transition. Eleven—including Germany, France, the Netherlands, and Ireland—have now released their own fossil fuel phaseout road maps. But in terms of a COP-wide commitment, agreements were essentially kicked down the line to this year’s meeting. 

 

Now, attendees are considering a draft agreement that appears far from final, with no clear main initiative or takeaway. The 18-page  “cover decision” was introduced Monday after a week of negotiations, but still represents more of a wishlist of competing ideals than a compromise. Part of the challenge is that, in the years it’s taken for countries to come anywhere near an agreement on these climate points, the playing field has changed dramatically.

 

Parts of the world have already surpassed 1.5 degrees Celsius of warming over pre-industrial levels. One recent study estimates that with current global emissions policies in place, temperatures could “overshoot” and surge to 2.7 degrees of warming by 2100. Negotiators want that fact taken into account for any final goals. 

 

Climate finance is a major issue, especially as developing nations are already in debt from dealing with climate-related disasters. Wealthy countries had pledged in 2009 to mobilize $100 billion per year by 2020 to help other nations with climate mitigation, but they missed their target. The crowning achievement at last year’s COP was a promise to deliver more money to developing countries hit hardest by climate change, but that pledge is already off to a slow start. One assessment suggests that the annual climate finance goal could fall $840 billion short of its ultimate target of  $1.3 trillion.

New Pressure Points

A new issue permeating COP this year is AI. Both AI and data centers were central focuses at September’s Climate Week NYC, much to the frustration of some climate activists and political scientists, including Leah Stokes, who told me in an interview that AI doomerism was overshadowing the impact of fossil fuels.

 

But AI is a big concern globally. Hyperscale data centers in the U.S. emit as much as the entire country of Denmark, according to a recent report from Harvard University researchers. COP31 attendees rolled out what they call the Antalya AI Pledge, which recognizes AI’s potential to cut and track emissions while cautioning against its climate risks. The pledge further asks for a commitment from governments and companies to run AI products with clean energy. Just nine countries so far have signed, along with Chinese global tech and e-commerce corporation Alibaba. U.N. leaders say they plan to keep the pledge open to signatories until next year’s COP conference.

 

Attendees are also pushing for a commitment to make polluters pay. One framework supports putting fines on industrial sectors responsible for air pollution that contributes to climate change. On Tuesday, the United Kingdom signed on to support the statement, joining Spain and five other African, Oceania, and Asian countries.

An Obvious Absence

Missing from the global discussions this week was a major world player and the second-largest contributor of global emissions: the United States.

 

The Trump administration sent no official representatives to the conference, and joined Afghanistan and Myanmar as the only three countries not to send negotiators. Instead, President Donald Trump is meeting in China with its President Xi Jinping and Russia President Vladimir Putin for the APEC Summit. The two-day economic meeting is expected to revolve around nuclear arms control, AI chips, and the war in Ukraine.

 

Eighteen members of Congress are at COP31 of their own accord to reaffirm Americans’ commitment to mitigate global warming.

 

“The United States has retreated from the world stage, and the world is moving on,” Democratic Illinois Rep. Jonathan Jackson told media outlet Devex. “We want to catch back up and let people know that not everyone in the United States agrees with the current direction.”

 

Outgoing California governor and likely presidential hopeful Gavin Newsom is also attending. Newsom was a bit of a star at last year’s summit. 

 

The timing is admittedly awkward: COP talks are happening as Congress is expected to pass a permitting reform bill this week, which some environmentalists consider to be a sweetheart deal for the fossil fuel industry and tech companies who want to see more data centers built. Others praise the bill for opening up federal land to more clean energy.

 

Both negotiations in Türkiye and in D.C. highlight the pitfalls of striving for a climate compromise between mutually exclusive, competing interests. 

 

That’s because the atmosphere doesn’t understand a climate pledge or a compromise backed by a handshake. It deals in facts alone. Science shows that fossil fuels must ultimately be phased out to avoid the worst-case climate scenarios. 

 

And while oil and gas and clean energy companies can co-exist in a happy equilibrium that benefits industries and the energy sector, that sort of compromise only leads to a compromised planet. 

Want me to look into The Understory of something? Send me an email!

 



BIOME

Join our membership community. Support our work, receive a complimentary subscription to Atmos Magazine, and more.

Learn More

Return to Title Slide

Can You Negotiate With a Warming Planet?

Newsletter