How Gaza’s Future Children Will Inherit the Trauma of Genocide

Photograph by Paolo Pellegrin / Magnum

How Gaza’s Future Children Will Inherit the Trauma of Genocide

WORDS BY JASON P. DINH

One year of Israeli genocide in Gaza could leave generational scars on the health, biology, and epigenetics of Palestinians who haven’t even been born or conceived.

This week marks one year of genocide in Gaza. Following the Hamas attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023, Israel’s military retaliation has since killed over 42,000 Palestinians; injured over 103,000 more; destroyed nearly 60% of Gaza’s buildings; displaced 90% of its population; and sent the region spiraling into what the head of the United Nations (U.N.) World Food Program has called a “full-blown famine.” 

 

The conditions are “incomparable” to any crisis in modern history, said Juliette Touma, communications director for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA).

 

“This is by far the largest humanitarian crisis that this agency has been through,” Touma said, noting that since 1948, UNRWA has provided aid in conflict zones including those in Syria, Lebanon, and the first and second intifadas in Palestine.

 

“I think we’ve passed the point in time where we describe what’s happening in Gaza as concerning. And I’m not sure I have the right words to describe the situation in Gaza. These are not living conditions,” Touma added. 

 

The survivors of the genocide are already suffering the consequences: grief, shattered families, starvation, chronic traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, depression, and more. Research from past humanitarian crises suggests that the health consequences could last the rest of their lives. And now, experts fear that the trauma of the genocide could be passed on to future generations of unborn Palestinians: on their psyche, health, and potentially even their epigenetics—the cellular processes that control how genes work without altering the DNA itself. 

 

“I’m really worried that these traumatic experiences aren’t only traumatic for the men and women and the children going through the crisis as it’s happening now, but it’s also going to affect the unborn children, and they’re going to carry the longest legacy,” said Tessa Roseboom, who studies early development and health at Amsterdam University Medical Center.

Studying the Descendants of Humanitarian Crises

Studies on the survivors of the Holocaust, the Rwandan Genocide, World War II, the Vietnam War, and the Civil War all suggest that the trauma of war can have multigenerational impacts on crisis survivors and their descendants. Perhaps the strongest evidence comes from the Dutch Hunger Winter of 1944 to 1945. 

 

Toward the end of World War II, major cities in the Netherlands faced a five-month food shortage. Daily rations in parts of the Nazi-occupied country were limited to less than 400 calories per day. Researchers, including Roseboom, have since traced the hospital records of thousands of people born around the time of the famine, as well as their children and grandchildren. The landmark studies that emerged from that research have established that the health effects of war are far from over after the ceasefire. 

 

For starters, people who experienced the Dutch famine in the womb had an increased risk of obesity, breast cancer, and mortality once they became adults decades later. They also had higher rates of cardiovascular disease, smaller brain volumes, and were more responsive to stress.

“I’m not sure I have the right words to describe the situation in Gaza. These are not living conditions.”

Juliette Touma
Communications director, UNRWA

What’s more, their children—the grandchildren of the people who were pregnant during the famine—were also affected. Even two generations after the famine ended, some newborns whose ancestors were malnourished had smaller body length and more fatty tissue; as children, their parents reported that they had more health issues; and as adults, some had higher body weight and BMI. These intergenerational effects have since been bolstered by research on other famines, like the Great Chinese Famine, which has shown that the children of survivors also have weakened cognitive ability, worse socioeconomic outcomes, and greater susceptibility to infectious diseases like tuberculosis.

 

“The health effects, the participation on the labor market—those are studies that have been replicated in situations in China, in Biafra, in Ukraine,” said Roseboom. “I feel much more confident that this is something that is biological, that is happening across settings.” 

The Epigenetics of Trauma

Precisely how the multigenerational effects of war and famine get transmitted is not yet clear. Most likely, there are several pathways. For instance, trauma could alter parenting, which could, in turn, affect a child’s behavior. Additionally, trauma can be passed on through biology. For example, when a pregnant person is stressed, the defenses in the placenta that normally shield a fetus from its parent’s stress hormones falter. “Marinating” a fetus in a parent’s stress hormones could hinder organ development and affect the baby’s health for the rest of its life, Roseboom said. 

 

Trauma can even affect future generations before they are conceived. Some scientists believe this occurs through mechanisms called epigenetics, the molecular processes that alter how genes work without changing the DNA itself. These include, for example, DNA methylation, a process in which chemical flags placed along the genome turn genes on or off. Survivors of the Holocaust have DNA methylation changes on a gene associated with stress regulation, and the survivors’ children do, too, suggesting that epigenetics might be heritable (though this remains controversial).

 

As of now, epigenetic inheritance of trauma remains a hypothesis, and a rather tenuous one in humans. “I think [the evidence] is weak,” said Hasan Khatib, who studies genetics and epigenetics at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. That’s because it is ethically and logistically challenging to study humans. To prove that epigenetic changes are inherited, researchers need to perform controlled experiments that track three to four generations of people—a high, perhaps impossible, bar to reach, Khatib said. 

 

Still, Khatib thinks that it’s feasible, perhaps even likely, that humans inherit trauma through epigenetics. That’s because a growing body of research has shown that it happens in nonhuman animals. 

 

His lab, for example, published a paper in 2022 on sheep, which he said is the first solid evidence of epigenetic inheritance in mammals. By feeding pairs of sheep brothers different foods, Khatib’s team showed that diet changes cause epigenetic modifications, which then alter the sheep’s physical traits—in this case, testicle size and muscle growth. The sheep’s sons had those same epigenetic and physical changes, and their grandsons did, too, despite not being directly exposed to the diet change themselves. 

 

That landmark finding is consistent with prior lab animal studies, including in other mammals like mice. The fact that human observational studies hint that this might be happening in people, too, is enough to raise concerns for Khatib.

 

“If it’s happening in these animals, then most likely, it’s happening in humans,” Khatib said. “I think this is the most important message of these animal models: that yes, it’s possible that in mammalian species we can inherit trauma and famine.” 

Generational Genocide in Gaza

Roseboom is less concerned about the precise mechanisms of intergenerational trauma than she is about minimizing it. Much of her work these days is to protect future generations and ensure they have the best possible environments to develop into their full potential. That includes working with a group of concerned medical experts to improve humanitarian aid in Gaza, as well as providing input during the consultation phase of the newly adopted U.N. Declaration on Future Generations. 

 

“Creating an environment in which every human being gets a chance to develop to its full potential is something that no one could be against,” Roseboom said. 

“Creating an environment in which every human being gets a chance to develop to its full potential is something that no one could be against.”

Tessa Roseboom
Researcher, Amsterdam University Medical Center

Still, there’s no end in sight to the unlivable environment in Gaza. If anything, the conflict appears to be expanding. Last month, Israel escalated its military attacks against Hezbollah, the Iran-backed militia group operating in Lebanon. Israel appears to have detonated pagers and walkie-talkies used by the group; launched air strikes in Lebanon; and last week, began a ground invasion of the country. Already, the conflict has killed over 1,400 Lebanese people and displaced a fifth of the nation’s population. Iran fired a barrage of missiles at Israel in retaliation, an act Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed Iran “will pay for.” Experts warn of all-out war between Israel, Hezbollah, and Iran, and although the U.S. and other allied nations have called for a ceasefire, Netanyahu recently said that he would continue the attacks “with all our might.”

 

Touma of UNRWA says that for people concerned about the intergenerational humanitarian crisis in Gaza and beyond, the most impactful thing they can do is to pressure politicians to reach a ceasefire. That deal should include the release of hostages, who are experiencing torture and starvation that could leave intergenerational scars. It should also include the resumption of humanitarian aid, which will alleviate the burden of famine that will likely ripple for generations. Donating to aid agencies can help, but what’s critical now is ending the crisis at its root. 

 

“It is long overdue. A ceasefire is a win-win because it will bring respite to the people of Gaza who have been going through this endless nightmare for the past year, but also respite for the people of Israel,” she said. “It is time to find a peaceful solution to this decades-long conflict. It is time for the Palestinians and the Israelis to live in peace.” 


Biome

Join our membership community. Support our work, receive a complimentary subscription to Atmos Magazine, and more.

Learn More

Return to Title Slide

How Gaza’s Future Children Will Inherit the Trauma of Genocide

Newsletter